GET https://rct.dev.bbntimes.com/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty

Response
200 OK
IP
18.219.123.56
Profiled on
Token
ec583a

ArticleController :: show

Request

GET Parameters

None

POST Parameters

None

Uploaded Files

None

Request Attributes

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\ArticleController::show"
_firewall_context 
"security.firewall.map.context.main"
_links 
Symfony\Component\WebLink\GenericLinkProvider {#3589
  -links: [
    3710 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3710
      -href: "/build/runtime.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3708 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3708
      -href: "/build/644.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3707 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3707
      -href: "/build/502.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3706 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3706
      -href: "/build/app.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3705 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3705
      -href: "/build/view-more.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3704 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3704
      -href: "/build/term-condition.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3703 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3703
      -href: "/build/contact.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3702 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3702
      -href: "/build/scroll-infinite-article.js"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "script"
      ]
    }
    3701 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3701
      -href: "/build/app.css"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "style"
      ]
    }
    3700 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3700
      -href: "/build/cookie-style.css"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "style"
      ]
    }
    3699 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3699
      -href: "/build/term-condition-css.css"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "style"
      ]
    }
    3698 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3698
      -href: "/build/contact-css.css"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "style"
      ]
    }
    3697 => Symfony\Component\WebLink\Link {#3697
      -href: "/build/comment-css.css"
      -rel: [
        "preload" => "preload"
      ]
      -attributes: [
        "as" => "style"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
_route 
"article_show"
_route_params 
[
  "category" => "science"
  "slug" => "ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
]
_security_firewall_run 
"_security_main"
_stopwatch_token 
"a06d06"
category 
"science"
slug 
"ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"

Request Headers

Header Value
accept 
"*/*"
accept-encoding 
"gzip, br, zstd, deflate"
connection 
"close"
cookie 
"PHPSESSID=82htl8kuk2nk2njd3pggl3ornt"
host 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
user-agent 
"Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)"
x-php-ob-level 
"1"

Request Content

Request content not available (it was retrieved as a resource).

Response

Response Headers

Header Value
cache-control 
"no-cache, private"
content-type 
"text/html; charset=UTF-8"
date 
"Sat, 22 Feb 2025 13:24:21 GMT"
link 
"</build/runtime.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/644.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/502.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/app.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/view-more.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/term-condition.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/contact.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/scroll-infinite-article.js>; rel="preload"; as="script",</build/app.css>; rel="preload"; as="style",</build/cookie-style.css>; rel="preload"; as="style",</build/term-condition-css.css>; rel="preload"; as="style",</build/contact-css.css>; rel="preload"; as="style",</build/comment-css.css>; rel="preload"; as="style""
x-debug-token 
"ec583a"

Cookies

Request Cookies

Key Value
PHPSESSID 
"82htl8kuk2nk2njd3pggl3ornt"

Response Cookies

No response cookies

Session 6

Session Metadata

Key Value
Created 
"Sat, 22 Feb 25 13:24:04 +0000"
Last used 
"Sat, 22 Feb 25 13:24:20 +0000"
Lifetime 
0

Session Attributes

Attribute Value
_csrf/https-comment 
"2sPuJoZITneCkZOidQ60elacTf7BfPZd0lYIlHwV67w"
_csrf/https-cookie_accept 
"A6sb3WUMtEdYzpJSSjVm-6znpkuHeeg2nRPiogS3i2E"

Session Usage

6 Usages
Stateless check enabled
Usage
Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage:76
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/TokenStorage/SessionTokenStorage.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "start"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/CsrfTokenManager.php"
    "line" => 69
    "function" => "hasToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/Csrf/Type/FormTypeCsrfExtension.php"
    "line" => 82
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\CsrfTokenManager"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 134
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\Csrf\Type\FormTypeCsrfExtension"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 128
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Form.php"
    "line" => 908
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/ArticleController.php"
    "line" => 220
    "function" => "createView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Form"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "show"
    "class" => "App\Controller\ArticleController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]
Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage:79
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/TokenStorage/SessionTokenStorage.php"
    "line" => 79
    "function" => "has"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/CsrfTokenManager.php"
    "line" => 69
    "function" => "hasToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/Csrf/Type/FormTypeCsrfExtension.php"
    "line" => 82
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\CsrfTokenManager"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 134
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\Csrf\Type\FormTypeCsrfExtension"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 128
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Form.php"
    "line" => 908
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/ArticleController.php"
    "line" => 220
    "function" => "createView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Form"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "show"
    "class" => "App\Controller\ArticleController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]
Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage:52
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/TokenStorage/SessionTokenStorage.php"
    "line" => 52
    "function" => "has"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/CsrfTokenManager.php"
    "line" => 70
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/Csrf/Type/FormTypeCsrfExtension.php"
    "line" => 82
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\CsrfTokenManager"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 134
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\Csrf\Type\FormTypeCsrfExtension"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 128
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Form.php"
    "line" => 908
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/ArticleController.php"
    "line" => 220
    "function" => "createView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Form"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "show"
    "class" => "App\Controller\ArticleController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]
Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage:56
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/TokenStorage/SessionTokenStorage.php"
    "line" => 56
    "function" => "get"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-csrf/CsrfTokenManager.php"
    "line" => 70
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\TokenStorage\SessionTokenStorage"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/Csrf/Type/FormTypeCsrfExtension.php"
    "line" => 82
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\CsrfTokenManager"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 134
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\Csrf\Type\FormTypeCsrfExtension"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/ResolvedFormType.php"
    "line" => 128
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Extension/DataCollector/Proxy/ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy.php"
    "line" => 95
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\ResolvedFormType"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/form/Form.php"
    "line" => 908
    "function" => "finishView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Extension\DataCollector\Proxy\ResolvedTypeDataCollectorProxy"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/ArticleController.php"
    "line" => 220
    "function" => "createView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Form\Form"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "show"
    "class" => "App\Controller\ArticleController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]
Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage:41
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-core/Authentication/Token/Storage/UsageTrackingTokenStorage.php"
    "line" => 41
    "function" => "getMetadataBag"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/twig-bridge/AppVariable.php"
    "line" => 103
    "function" => "getToken"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Extension/CoreExtension.php"
    "line" => 1635
    "function" => "getUser"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bridge\Twig\AppVariable"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/var/cache/dev/twig/a4/a456f2f504a18cd81037fa69e543310c.php"
    "line" => 200
    "function" => "twig_get_attribute"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 394
    "function" => "doDisplay"
    "class" => "__TwigTemplate_824a013e4f3f4a68e03a2d244e765025"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 367
    "function" => "displayWithErrorHandling"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 379
    "function" => "display"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/TemplateWrapper.php"
    "line" => 38
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php"
    "line" => 280
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\TemplateWrapper"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 448
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\Environment"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 453
    "function" => "doRenderView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 253
    "function" => "doRender"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/AppController.php"
    "line" => 126
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "renderHeader"
    "class" => "App\Controller\AppController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpCache/SubRequestHandler.php"
    "line" => 86
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Fragment/InlineFragmentRenderer.php"
    "line" => 78
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpCache\SubRequestHandler"
    "type" => "::"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Fragment/FragmentHandler.php"
    "line" => 83
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Fragment\InlineFragmentRenderer"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/DependencyInjection/LazyLoadingFragmentHandler.php"
    "line" => 47
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Fragment\FragmentHandler"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/twig-bridge/Extension/HttpKernelRuntime.php"
    "line" => 44
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\DependencyInjection\LazyLoadingFragmentHandler"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/var/cache/dev/twig/b9/b9cb140abab7ef4ef8cb398831c75ac0.php"
    "line" => 207
    "function" => "renderFragment"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bridge\Twig\Extension\HttpKernelRuntime"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 171
    "function" => "block_header"
    "class" => "__TwigTemplate_dc67cdc305f050f0a27ba7ef152f05af"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/var/cache/dev/twig/b9/b9cb140abab7ef4ef8cb398831c75ac0.php"
    "line" => 91
    "function" => "displayBlock"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 394
    "function" => "doDisplay"
    "class" => "__TwigTemplate_dc67cdc305f050f0a27ba7ef152f05af"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 367
    "function" => "displayWithErrorHandling"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/var/cache/dev/twig/c3/c336f4e76fc20e4db84e3be131276b68.php"
    "line" => 52
    "function" => "display"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 394
    "function" => "doDisplay"
    "class" => "__TwigTemplate_3ce0324a396de697d1fad9fabd68df72"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 367
    "function" => "displayWithErrorHandling"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php"
    "line" => 379
    "function" => "display"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/TemplateWrapper.php"
    "line" => 38
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\Template"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php"
    "line" => 280
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\TemplateWrapper"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 448
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Twig\Environment"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 453
    "function" => "doRenderView"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/framework-bundle/Controller/AbstractController.php"
    "line" => 253
    "function" => "doRender"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/src/Controller/ArticleController.php"
    "line" => 277
    "function" => "render"
    "class" => "Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 181
    "function" => "show"
    "class" => "App\Controller\ArticleController"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\ContextListener:171
Show trace 
[
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/security-http/Firewall/ContextListener.php"
    "line" => 171
    "function" => "remove"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Session\Session"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/event-dispatcher/Debug/WrappedListener.php"
    "line" => 116
    "function" => "onKernelResponse"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\ContextListener"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/event-dispatcher/EventDispatcher.php"
    "line" => 220
    "function" => "__invoke"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\Debug\WrappedListener"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/event-dispatcher/EventDispatcher.php"
    "line" => 56
    "function" => "callListeners"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\EventDispatcher"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/event-dispatcher/Debug/TraceableEventDispatcher.php"
    "line" => 139
    "function" => "dispatch"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\EventDispatcher"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 214
    "function" => "dispatch"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\Debug\TraceableEventDispatcher"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 202
    "function" => "filterResponse"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/HttpKernel.php"
    "line" => 76
    "function" => "handleRaw"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/http-kernel/Kernel.php"
    "line" => 197
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\HttpKernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/symfony/runtime/Runner/Symfony/HttpKernelRunner.php"
    "line" => 35
    "function" => "handle"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\HttpKernel\Kernel"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    "line" => 29
    "function" => "run"
    "class" => "Symfony\Component\Runtime\Runner\Symfony\HttpKernelRunner"
    "type" => "->"
  ]
  [
    "file" => "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
    "line" => 5
    "args" => [
      "/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/vendor/autoload_runtime.php"
    ]
    "function" => "require_once"
  ]
]

Flashes

Flashes

No flash messages were created.

Server Parameters

Server Parameters

Defined in .env

Key Value
APP_ENV 
"dev"
APP_SECRET 
"0a988e63f011514eaabfc650b599af4d"
CORS_ALLOW_ORIGIN 
"*"
DATABASE_URL 
"mysql://bbndb_rctuser:33F5W25z40or0f7@localhost:3306/rct_bbntimes"
GOOGLE_RECAPTCHA_SECRET_KEY 
"6LdV5fgpAAAAANxzTG8ZMfIjil1wu-1vrQvnUt-x"
GOOGLE_RECAPTCHA_SITE_KEY 
"6LdV5fgpAAAAAENKcn73MJAhQrbtQeqgyC4wDLMP"
MAILER_DSN 
"smtp://no-reply%40rct.dev.bbntimes.com:Bl6%26gLD48%26Of919@rct.dev.bbntimes.com:465"
MARIADB_PASSWORD 
"i!87pK&!85ezc8"

Defined as regular env variables

Key Value
APP_DEBUG 
"1"
BASE 
"/public"
CONTEXT_DOCUMENT_ROOT 
"/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
CONTEXT_PREFIX 
""
DOCUMENT_ROOT 
"/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
FCGI_ROLE 
"RESPONDER"
GATEWAY_INTERFACE 
"CGI/1.1"
HTTPS 
"on"
HTTP_ACCEPT 
"*/*"
HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING 
"gzip, br, zstd, deflate"
HTTP_CONNECTION 
"close"
HTTP_COOKIE 
"PHPSESSID=82htl8kuk2nk2njd3pggl3ornt"
HTTP_HOST 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
HTTP_USER_AGENT 
"Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)"
PASSENGER_COMPILE_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
PASSENGER_DOWNLOAD_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
PATH 
"/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin:/snap/bin"
PHP_SELF 
"/public/index.php"
PP_CUSTOM_PHP_CGI_INDEX 
"plesk-php81-fastcgi"
PP_CUSTOM_PHP_INI 
"/var/www/vhosts/system/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/etc/php.ini"
QUERY_STRING 
""
REDIRECT_BASE 
"/public"
REDIRECT_HTTPS 
"on"
REDIRECT_PASSENGER_COMPILE_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
REDIRECT_PASSENGER_DOWNLOAD_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_HTTPS 
"on"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_PASSENGER_COMPILE_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_PASSENGER_DOWNLOAD_NATIVE_SUPPORT_BINARY 
"0"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_SCRIPT_URI 
"https://rct.dev.bbntimes.com/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_SCRIPT_URL 
"/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_SSL_TLS_SNI 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_STATUS 
"200"
REDIRECT_REDIRECT_UNIQUE_ID 
"Z7nQBZDyWLT8YV1VjBpTFwAAAIc"
REDIRECT_SCRIPT_URI 
"https://rct.dev.bbntimes.com/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
REDIRECT_SCRIPT_URL 
"/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
REDIRECT_SSL_TLS_SNI 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
REDIRECT_STATUS 
"200"
REDIRECT_UNIQUE_ID 
"Z7nQBZDyWLT8YV1VjBpTFwAAAIc"
REDIRECT_URL 
"/public/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
REMOTE_ADDR 
"18.219.123.56"
REMOTE_PORT 
"31869"
REQUEST_METHOD 
"GET"
REQUEST_SCHEME 
"https"
REQUEST_TIME 
1740230661
REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT 
1740230661.1335
REQUEST_URI 
"/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
SCRIPT_FILENAME 
"/var/www/vhosts/dev.bbntimes.com/rct.dev.bbntimes.com/public/index.php"
SCRIPT_NAME 
"/public/index.php"
SCRIPT_URI 
"https://rct.dev.bbntimes.com/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
SCRIPT_URL 
"/science/ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
SERVER_ADDR 
"5.196.1.209"
SERVER_ADMIN 
"[no address given]"
SERVER_NAME 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
SERVER_PORT 
"443"
SERVER_PROTOCOL 
"HTTP/1.1"
SERVER_SIGNATURE 
"<address>Apache Server at rct.dev.bbntimes.com Port 443</address>\n"
SERVER_SOFTWARE 
"Apache"
SSL_TLS_SNI 
"rct.dev.bbntimes.com"
SYMFONY_DOTENV_VARS 
"APP_ENV,APP_SECRET,DATABASE_URL,MARIADB_PASSWORD,CORS_ALLOW_ORIGIN,MAILER_DSN,GOOGLE_RECAPTCHA_SECRET_KEY,GOOGLE_RECAPTCHA_SITE_KEY"
UNIQUE_ID 
"Z7nQBZDyWLT8YV1VjBpTFwAAAIc"

Sub Requests 6

CookieController :: renderAnalysis (token = b0c239)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\CookieController::renderAnalysis"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"adb95e"

AppController :: renderHeader (token = 636dc9)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\AppController::renderHeader"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"7ddbd5"
slug 
"home"

ArticleController :: trendingArticle (token = a6690d)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\ArticleController::trendingArticle"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"b9f744"
category 
"Science"

ArticleController :: relatedArticles (token = 0552a9)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\ArticleController::relatedArticles"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"44b2a5"
current_article 
App\Entity\Article {#1094
  -id: 17779
  -title: "AI and the Challenge of Causal Reasoning and Reasoning under Uncertainty"
  -slug: "ai-and-the-challenge-of-causal-reasoning-and-reasoning-under-uncertainty"
  -introtext: "<p id="ember42" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems have made remarkable strides.</p>\r\n"
  -content: """
    \r\n
    <p class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">In recent years, AI systems have achieved human-level or even superhuman performance in specific tasks such as image recognition, natural language processing, and game-playing.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember42" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Despite these impressive achievements, current AI systems still struggle with fundamental aspects of intelligence that humans possess – the ability to reason about causality and handle uncertainty.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember43" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Causal Reasoning:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember44" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Causal reasoning is the process of understanding and inferring the underlying causal relationships between events or variables in a system. It involves identifying the root causes of observed phenomena, predicting the effects of interventions or actions, and reasoning counterfactually about alternative scenarios.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember45" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Most contemporary AI systems, particularly those based on deep learning and neural networks, excel at pattern recognition and correlational reasoning. They can identify statistical associations and patterns in data, but they often lack the ability to reason about the causal mechanisms that generate those patterns.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember46" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">This limitation poses significant challenges in domains where causal understanding is crucial, such as scientific discovery, decision-making under uncertainty, and policy evaluation. For example, in healthcare, identifying mere correlations between symptoms and diseases is insufficient; understanding the underlying causal mechanisms is essential for effective diagnosis, treatment selection, and developing targeted interventions.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember47" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Reasoning under Uncertainty</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember48" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Real-world problems are often characterized by uncertainty, incomplete information, and noisy or ambiguous data. The ability to reason effectively under such conditions is a hallmark of human intelligence, allowing us to make informed decisions, formulate hypotheses, and adapt to changing environments.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember49" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">However, many AI systems struggle with reasoning under uncertainty, particularly when faced with novel situations or scenarios that deviate from their training data. This limitation is partly due to the inherent brittleness of traditional AI approaches, which often rely on deterministic rules or fixed models that fail to capture the complexity and variability of real-world environments.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember50" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Probabilistic Reasoning</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember51" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">To address the challenges of causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty, researchers have turned to probabilistic approaches and frameworks that explicitly model and reason about uncertainty. These include techniques such as Bayesian networks, probabilistic graphical models, and causal inference methods.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember52" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Bayesian networks, for example, provide a principled way to represent and reason about causal relationships and uncertainty using probability theory. They allow for the incorporation of prior knowledge, evidence, and observed data to update beliefs and make inferences about unobserved variables or the effects of interventions.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember53" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Causal Inference</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember54" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Causal inference is a field of study that focuses on deriving causal relationships from observational or experimental data. It involves techniques such as structural equation modeling, instrumental variables, and potential outcomes frameworks (e.g., Rubin's causal model).</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember55" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">By leveraging these methods, AI systems can move beyond mere correlational analysis and gain a deeper understanding of the causal mechanisms underlying observed phenomena. This is particularly valuable in domains such as epidemiology, economics, and policy evaluation, where causal knowledge is essential for informed decision-making and intervention design.</p>\r\n
    <p><img src="/images/Challenges_and_Approahes_in_AI.png" alt="Challenges_and_Approahes_in_AI.png" width="601" height="338" /></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember57" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Challenges and Approaches:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember58" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Developing AI systems capable of robust causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty is a formidable challenge that requires addressing several key issues:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember59" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">1.<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><strong>Representation and Knowledge Integration</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember60" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>AI systems must be able to represent and integrate various forms of knowledge, including structured domain knowledge, empirical data, and causal relationships. This involves developing expressive and scalable representations that can capture the complexities of real-world systems and facilitate effective reasoning.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember61" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">2.<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><strong>Counterfactual Reasoning</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember62" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>The ability to reason counterfactually – considering alternative scenarios and assessing the potential outcomes of interventions or actions – is a critical component of causal reasoning. AI systems need to develop mechanisms for generating and evaluating counterfactual scenarios, drawing on causal models and domain knowledge.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember63" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">3.<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><strong>Dealing with Confounding and Bias</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember64" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>In observational data, confounding factors and biases can lead to spurious correlations or incorrect causal inferences. AI systems must incorporate techniques to identify and account for confounding variables, selection biases, and other sources of bias to ensure reliable causal conclusions.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember65" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">4.<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><strong>Transfer Learning and Domain Adaptation</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember66" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>AI systems should be able to leverage knowledge and causal models learned from one domain or context and adapt them to new scenarios or environments. This requires developing transfer learning and domain adaptation techniques that can effectively transfer causal knowledge while accounting for domain shifts and distribution changes.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember67" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">5.<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><strong>Explainable and Interpretable Models</strong>:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember68" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>As AI systems become more complex and are tasked with making critical decisions, it is essential that their reasoning processes and causal inferences are interpretable and explainable to humans. This not only promotes trust and accountability but also facilitates the validation and refinement of causal models.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember69" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Researchers have proposed various approaches to tackle these challenges, including:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember70" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">-<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><em>Causal Discovery Algorithms</em>: These algorithms aim to automatically learn causal models from observational data, using techniques such as constraint-based methods (e.g., PC algorithm), score-based methods (e.g., Greedy Equivalence Search), and hybrid approaches.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember71" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">-<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><em>Structural Causal Models (SCMs):</em><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>SCMs provide a formal framework for representing and reasoning about causal relationships, leveraging concepts from graphical models, structural equation modeling, and causal inference. Advances in SCM learning and inference algorithms have enabled their application in various domains.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember72" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">-<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><em>Counterfactual Reasoning Frameworks</em>: Approaches like potential outcomes frameworks (e.g., Rubin's causal model) and structural equation models with counterfactual reasoning capabilities have been developed to enable AI systems to reason about alternative scenarios and interventions.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember73" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">-<span class="white-space-pre"> </span><em>Uncertainty-Aware Learning</em>: Techniques such as Bayesian deep learning, probabilistic programming, and uncertainty estimation methods aim to incorporate uncertainty into the learning and prediction processes of AI models, improving their ability to reason under uncertainty and quantify their confidence in predictions.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember74" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Applications and Real-World Impact:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember75" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">The ability to perform effective causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty has numerous applications across various domains, with the potential to drive significant real-world impact:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember76" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>1. Healthcare and Biomedical Sciences:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember77" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Understanding causal mechanisms of diseases and biological processes</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember78" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Identifying risk factors and developing targeted interventions</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember79" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Personalized medicine and treatment optimization</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember80" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Causal discovery from electronic health records and observational data</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember81" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>2. Scientific Discovery and Experimental Design:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember82" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Automating hypothesis generation and experiment design</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember83" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Identifying causal factors in complex natural phenomena</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember84" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Accelerating scientific breakthroughs through causal reasoning</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember85" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>3. Decision-Making and Policy Evaluation:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember86" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Assessing the causal impact of interventions and policy decisions</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember87" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Counterfactual reasoning for decision support and risk assessment</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember88" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Robust decision-making under uncertainty in domains like finance, economics, and public policy</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember89" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>4. Robotics and Autonomous Systems:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember90" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Causal reasoning for task planning and decision-making in uncertain environments</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember91" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Counterfactual reasoning for safe exploration and failure recovery</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember92" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Adapting to changing conditions and transferring causal knowledge across domains</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember93" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>5. Fairness and Bias Mitigation:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember94" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Identifying and mitigating causal pathways leading to biased decisions</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember95" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Counterfactual reasoning for fairness evaluation and debiasing</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember96" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>6. Explainable AI and Human-AI Collaboration:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember97" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Providing causal explanations for AI decisions and predictions</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember98" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Enabling human-AI collaboration through interpretable causal models</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember99" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>- Building trust and accountability in AI systems</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember100" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">Despite the significant challenges, advances in causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty have the potential to push the boundaries of AI beyond narrow, specialized tasks and towards more robust and generalizable intelligence.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember101" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">However, it is crucial to address the ethical and societal implications of these technologies, such as ensuring fairness, privacy, and accountability, and mitigating potential negative impacts or unintended consequences.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember102" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>Future Directions and Conclusion:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember103" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">The pursuit of AI systems capable of causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty is a long-term endeavor that will require sustained research efforts and interdisciplinary collaborations. Here are some future directions and considerations:</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember104" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>1. Hybrid Approaches and Neuro-Symbolic Integration:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember105" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>Combining the strengths of neural networks and symbolic reasoning approaches through neuro-symbolic integration may unlock new avenues for causal reasoning and uncertainty handling. Leveraging the pattern recognition capabilities of deep learning with the interpretability and compositionality of symbolic systems could lead to more robust and transparent AI models.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember106" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>2. Multimodal Causal Reasoning:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember107" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>Developing AI systems that can reason about causal relationships across multiple modalities, such as vision, language, and physical interactions, is an important challenge. This will enable AI to better understand and interact with the rich, multimodal environments encountered in the real world.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember108" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>3. Scalable and Efficient Inference:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember109" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>As causal models and reasoning frameworks become more complex, scalable and efficient inference algorithms will be crucial for practical applications. This may involve leveraging advances in parallel computing, approximate inference techniques, and specialized hardware accelerators.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember110" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>4. Causal Representation Learning:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember111" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>Exploring methods for learning expressive and disentangled representations of causal variables and mechanisms directly from data could pave the way for more data-efficient and transferable causal reasoning capabilities.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember112" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>5. Human-AI Collaboration and Interactive Learning:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember113" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>Combining human expertise and domain knowledge with AI-driven causal discovery and reasoning could lead to more robust and interpretable models. Interactive learning approaches that facilitate human-AI collaboration and knowledge exchange may be key to advancing causal reasoning capabilities.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember114" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><strong>6. Causal Benchmarks and Evaluation Frameworks:</strong></p>\r\n
    <p id="ember115" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph"><span class="white-space-pre"> </span>Developing comprehensive benchmarks and evaluation frameworks for causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty is essential for measuring progress, comparing different approaches, and identifying remaining challenges.</p>\r\n
    <p id="ember116" class="ember-view reader-content-blocks__paragraph">While significant challenges lie ahead, the pursuit of AI systems capable of robust causal reasoning and reasoning under uncertainty holds the promise of unlocking a new era of intelligent systems that can truly understand and interact with the complexities of the real world. By addressing these fundamental aspects of intelligence, AI has the potential to drive scientific discovery, enable more informed decision-making, and foster deeper human-AI collaboration across various domains.</p>
    """
  -user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#1092 …}
  -createdAt: DateTime @1718275004 {#1145
    date: 2024-06-13 10:36:44.0 UTC (+00:00)
  }
  -updatedAt: DateTime @1718293705 {#1150
    date: 2024-06-13 15:48:25.0 UTC (+00:00)
  }
  -deletedAt: null
  -category: App\Entity\Category {#445 …}
  -status: "published"
  -imageCard: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\File {#1184 …}
  -ImageHeader: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\File {#1184 …}
  -featured: false
  -mainView: false
  -clicks: 3238
  -comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1125 …}
  -reviewed_at: DateTime @1718275004 {#1148
    date: 2024-06-13 10:36:44.0 UTC (+00:00)
  }
  -metakey: "AI and the Challenge of Causal Reasoning and Reasoning under Uncertainty"
  -metadesc: "Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems have made remarkable strides in recent years, achieving human-level or even superhuman performance in specific tasks such as image recognition, natural language processing, and game-playing."
  -robots: null
  -publishedAt: DateTime @1718275004 {#1147
    date: 2024-06-13 10:36:44.0 UTC (+00:00)
  }
  -canonical: null
  -superTag: null
}

AppController :: renderFooter (token = e7e67d)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\AppController::renderFooter"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"00592b"

CookieController :: renderCookie (token = 0b4114)

Key Value
_controller 
"App\Controller\CookieController::renderCookie"
_format 
"html"
_locale 
"en"
_stopwatch_token 
"655bf9"